In St. Louis, Dr. R. C. Harris was called to treat six-year-old Bessie Baker for a severe case of diphtheria. As a precaution he gave antitoxin to Bessie and to her younger sister and baby brother as well. Diphtheria did not kill any of the three children. At the end of October 1901, all three died of tetanus instead.

The city's health department traced the serum to Jim, a retired milk-wagon horse used to produce the city's antitoxin. Jim had been bled on September 30, showed signs of tetanus the next day, and was destroyed on October 2. The department's own records stated that none of that September 30 blood had ever left the building. City coroner Robert Funkhouser's inquest found otherwise: some of it had been bottled and labeled August 24, the date of an earlier, healthy draw. The two draws had reached whoever bottled them with no label on either, to be told apart only by a department worker's memory of which flask was which.

Nobody had tested the September 30 serum on a guinea pig before it left the building, the one safeguard a dose was supposed to pass before it reached a patient. The city bacteriologist, Amand Ravold, had skipped that test. His assistant, Martin Schmidt, had known it and said nothing, out of friendship for Ravold, until he testified under oath more than a month later. By the time the inquest finished taking testimony, thirteen children were dead. Ravold was dismissed and held responsible. The worker who had carried the unlabeled flasks was dismissed as well, for contradictions in his own testimony, though the inquest assigned him no blame for the deaths themselves. Neither man was charged with a crime.

That same autumn, nine children in Camden, New Jersey, died of tetanus carried in a contaminated batch of smallpox vaccine. Congress answered both tragedies with the Biologics Control Act, signed without ceremony on July 1, 1902. The law required a federal license to manufacture any virus, serum, toxin, or antitoxin sold across a state line, gave inspectors the right to walk into the plant that made it, and ordered every package marked with the manufacturer's name and a date past which it could no longer answer for what was inside.

A loaf of bread carries no mark of the field it grew in, and a coin carries none of the mine it came from. Until 1902, a bottle of antitoxin carried nothing either, beyond whatever a label said and a worker remembered. What changed that July was not the horse's blood. It was who, by law, had to answer for the date on the bottle.